Description of the Report 2017

This report ranks graduate programs primarily on the basis of the quality of faculty. In October 2017, we conducted an on-line survey of approximately 550 philosophers throughout the English-speaking world. The survey was built using Qualtrics survey software and run by the Center for Innovation in Teaching and Research (CITR) at Western Illinois University. 274 philosophers responded and completed some or all of the surveys. The survey presented 91 faculty lists, from the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, and Australia and New Zealand. Note that there are some 110 PhD-granting programs in the U.S. alone, but it would be unduly burdensome for evaluators to ask them to evaluate all these programs each year. The top programs in each region were selected for evaluation, plus a few additional programs are included each year to “test the waters.”

The faculty lists are based on current information as to their shape for fall 2018, and are confined to full- or part-time faculty (status indicated), excluding adjuncts. Emeritus faculty members were also excluded. A penultimate copy of the draft list can be found here (LR link to file). Or ask W-B if they want a PDF they host on their site.

The lists that followed indicated which faculty were age 70-74 in 2018 with an *, and which were 75 or older in 2018 with a #, which were part-time, and which were philosophers or cognate faculty in other units at the university, but involved with the supervision of PhD students.

Different respondents had different “centers of gravity” in their scoring: some gave no 5s, others gave no score lower than a 2. It was also clear that respondents had different philosophies of evaluation: some clearly tried to consider the breadth of strength in a department, while others ranked a program highly or lowly based simply on its strength in his or her fields. The range of evaluations for single departments should be a cautionary note to all undergraduates about relying too much on the advice of just one or two faculty advisors. Idiosyncrasy abounds, even at top departments!

As in the past, we did not include the name of the university with the faculty lists. This has proved beneficial in forcing evaluators to respond to the current faculty. As one respondent put it a few years ago: “surprisingly tough to say what I think, without the institutional halo effect front loaded.”

The survey prompt for each list of faculty was:

Please rate the overall quality of the graduate program’s faculty.
The survey taker was then given a dropdown menu from which to select a ranking:

At the top of the list there was a blank for non-responses. The blank was the default for all responses even in the specialty areas.

The invitation letter gave invitees instructions on several matters, including which schools and specialty areas to rate. Specifically they were told: “Individuals should NOT rate their Ph.D. granting institution or graduate programs that employs them. The editors will “clean” the data of any such stray ratings.” All of the improper and stray ratings of this sort were removed from the data set before the calculation of the means in both the overall ratings and the specialty ratings.

“Faculty quality” should be taken to encompass the quality of philosophical work and talent represented by the faculty and the range of areas they cover, with the two weighted as you think appropriate. Since the rankings are used by prospective students, about to embark on a multi-year course of study, you may also take in to account, as you see fit, considerations like the status (full-time, part-time) of the faculty; the age of the faculty (as a somewhat tenuous guide to prospective availability, not quality); and the quality of training the faculty provide, to the extent you have information about this.

Evaluators were selected with an eye to balance, in terms of area, age and educational background–though since, in all cases, the opinions of research-active faculty were sought, there was, necessarily, a large number of alumni of the top programs represented. Approximately half those surveyed were philosophers who had filled out the surveys in previous years; the other half were nominated by members of the Advisory Board, who picked research-active faculty in their fields.

Despite the increase in the total number, and diversity, of respondents, the results were remarkably stable from prior years: where there were changes, there were rational reasons for those changes.

Here are the philosophers, by field, who filled out reputational surveys this year. The school from which the evaluator received the PhD (or equivalent) is listed in parentheses. A very rough characterization of the philosopher’s area(s) is given in the last column. Here are the 274 evaluators who completed some or all of the overall and specialty survey.

Name	PhD School	Current School	AREAS
Anna Alexandrova	University of California, San Diego	Cambridge University	PS&M, M&E
Torin Alter	University of California, Los Angeles	University of Alabama	M&E
Mark Alznauer	University of Chicago	Northwestern University	History
Kristin Andrews	University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul	York University , Toronto	PS&M
Stephen Angle	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	Wesleyn	Value, Chinese
Kwame Anthony Appiah	Cambridge University	New York University	Race, Feminism, Value
Avery Archer	University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program	George Washington University	M&E, Value, PS&M
Andre Ariew	University of Arizona	University of Missouri	PS&M
Brad Armendt	University of Illinois, Chicago	Arizona State University	PS&M, M&E
Joachim Aufderheide	University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program	King's College, London	History
Murat Aydede	University of Maryland	University of British Columbia	M&E, PS&M
David Bakhurst	Oxford University	Queen's University	M&E, Value
Rachel Barney	Princeton University	University of Toronto	History, Value
Jeffrey Barrett	Columbia University	University of California, Irvine	PS&M, M&E
John Bengson	University of Texas, Austin	University of Wisconsin	M&E, Value
Jose Bermudez	Cambridge University	Texas A&M University	M&E, PS&M
Sven Bernecker	Stanford University	University of California, Irvine	M&E, PS&M
Jessica Berry	University of Texas, Austin	Georgia State University	History
Christopher Bertram	University College London	University of Bristol	Value
Cristina Bicchieri	Cambridge University	University of Pennsylvania	PS&M, Value, M&E
John Bickle	University of California, Irvine	Missisippi State University	PS&M, M&E
Alexander Bird	Cambridge University	University of Bristol	PS&M, M&E
Brian Bix	Oxford University	University of Minnesota	Value
Chris Bobonich	University of California, Berkeley	Stanford University	History, Value
Paul Boghossian	Princeton University	New York University	M&E
David Bourget	Australian National University	University of Western Ontario	M&E, PS&M
David Braddon-Mitchell	Australian National University	Sydney	M&E, PS&M
David Braun	University of California, Los Angeles	University at Buffalo	M&E
Lee Braver	Emory University	University of South Florida	History
Tad Brennan	Princeton University	Cornell University	History
Bill Brewer	Oxford University	King's College, London	M&E
Berit Brogaard	University at Buffalo	University of Miami	M&E, PS&M
John Brunero	Columbia University	University of Nebraska	Value
Lara Buchak	Princeton University	University of California, Berkeley	PS&M, M&E
Alex Byrne	Princeton University	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	M&E, PS&M
Agnes Callard	University of California, Berkeley	University of Chicago	History, M&E, Value
Taylor Carman	Stanford University	Columbia University	History
John Carriero	Harvard University	University of California, Los Angeles	History, M&E
Peter Carruthers	Oxford University	University of Maryland	M&E, PS&M, History
Thomas Carson	Brown University	Loyola/Chicago	Value, History
Victor Caston	University of Texas, Austin)	University of Michigan	History
Mazviita Chirimuuta	University of Bristol	University of Pittsburgh	PS&M, M&E
Maudemarie Clark	University of Wisconsin, Madison	University of California, Riverside	History
Jonathan Cohen	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	University of California, San Diego	M&E, Value, PS&M
Juan Comesaña	Brown University	University of Arizona	M&E
Kevin Connolly	University of Toronto	Minerva Schools at KGI	PS&M, M&E
Roger Crisp	Oxford University	Oxford University	Value
Steven Crowell	Yale University	Rice University	History
Javier Cumpa	Madrid)	Madrid	PS&M, M&E
Gregory Currie	University of California, Berkeley	University of York	Value, M&E
David Danks	University of California, San Diego	Carnegie Mellon University	PS&M
Stephen Darwall	University of Pittsburgh	Yale University	Value, History
Shamik Dasgupta	New York University	University of California, Berkeley	M&E, PS&M
Stephen Davies	University College London	University of Auckland	Value
Jake Davis	City University of New York Graduate Center	New York University	Chinese, Value, PS&M
Keith DeRose	University of California, Los Angeles	Yale University	M&E
Dan Devereux	University of Chicago	University of Virginia	History, Value
John Doris	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	Washington University St. Louis	Value, PS&M, M&E
Stephen Downes	Virginia Tech	University of Utah	PS&M, M&E
James Dreier	Princeton University	Brown University	Value
Julia Driver	Johns Hopkins University	Washington University St. Louis	Value
Gerald Dworkin	University of California, Berkeley	University of California, Davis	Value
David Ebrey	University of California, Los Angeles	University of California, Berkeley	History
William Edmundson	University of California, Berkeley	Georgia State University	Value
Frances Egan	University of Western Ontario	Rutgers University	M&E, PS&M
Marc Ereshefsky	University of Wisconsin, Madison	University of Calgary	PS&M
Jeremy Fantl	Brown University	University of Calgary	M&E
Matthew Festenstein	Cambridge University	York University , Toronto	History, Value
Johann Frick	Harvard University	Princeton University	Value
Daniel Garber	Harvard University	Princeton University	History, P&M
Sebastian Gardner	Cambridge University	University College London	History, Value
Aaron Garrett	New School SR	Boston University	History
Don Garrett	Yale University	New York University	History
Gerald Gaus	University of Pittsburgh	University of Arizona	Value, PS&M
Berys Gaut	Princeton University	St. Andrews/Stirling	Value
Ken Gemes	University of Pittsburgh	Birkbeck	History, P&M
Rocco Gennaro	Syracuse University	Southern Indiana	M&E, Value, History, PS&M
Margaret Gilbert	Oxford University	University of California, Irvine	M&E, PS&M, Value
Michael Gill	University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill	University of Arizona	History
Anthony Gillies	University of Arizona	Rutgers University	PS&M, M&E
Michael Giudice	McMaster University	York University , Toronto	Value
Warren Goldfarb	Harvard University	Harvard University	M&E, PS&M, History
Alvin Goldman	Princeton University	Rutgers University	M&E, Value, PS&M
John Greco	Brown University	Saint Louis University	M&E
Leslie J. Green	Oxford University	Oxford University	Value, Feminism
Paul Griffiths	Australian National University	Sydney	PS&M
Stephen Grimm	University of Notre Dame	Fordham	M&E, Value
Gary Gutting	Saint Louis University	University of Notre Dame	History, PS&M, M&E
Paul Guyer	Harvard University	Brown University	History, Value
Ben Hale	Stony Brook	University of Colorado, Boulder	Value
Michael Hardimon	University of Chicago	University of California, San Diego	Race, History
William Harper	University of Rochester	University of Western Ontario	History
Verity Harte	Cambridge University	Yale University	History, M&E
John Hawthorne	Syracuse University	University of Southern California	M&E, History
Benjamin Hellie	Princeton University	University of Toronto	M&E, PS&M
David Hilbert	Stanford University	University of Illinois, Chicago	M&E, PS&M
Barry hilbert	Stanford University	Rutgers University	M&E, PS&M
Christopher Hill	Harvard University	Brown University	M&E
Chris Hitchcock	University of Pittsburgh	CalTech	PS&M, M&E
Wesley Holliday	Stanford University	University of California, Berkeley	M&E, PS&M
Robert Hopkins	Cambridge University	New York University	Value, M&E, History
Leon Horsten	Leuven	University of Bristol	PS&M, M&E
John Horty	University of Pittsburgh	University of Maryland	M&E, PS&M, Value
Stephen Houlgate	University of Edinburgh	University of Warwick	History
Andrew Huddleston	Princeton University	Birkbeck	History, Value
Michael Huemer	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	University of Colorado, Boulder	M&E, Value
Nicholas Huggett	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	University of Illinois, Chicago	PS&M
Simon Hutteger	Salzburg	University of California, Irvine	PS&M, M&E
Thomas Icard	Stanford University	Stanford University	M&E, PS&M
Brad Inwood	University of Toronto	Yale University	History
Terence Irwin	Princeton University	Oxford University	History, Value
Henry Jackman	University of Pittsburgh	York University , Toronto	History, M&E
Anne Jacobson	Oxford University	Harvard University	M&E, PS&M, Feminism
Scott Jenkins	Princeton University	University of Kansas	History
Robin Jeshion	University of Chicago	University of Southern California	M&E, History
Thomas Johansen	Cambridge University	Oslo	History, M&E, Value
Jim Joyce	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	University of Michigan	PS&M, M&E
Shelly Kagan	Princeton University	Yale University	Value
Peter Kail	Cambridge University	Oxford University	History, M&E
Paul Katsafanas	Harvard University	Boston University	Value, M&E, History
Dan Kaufman	University of Massachusetts, Amherst	University of Colorado, Boulder	History, M&E
John Kearns	Yale University	University at Buffalo	PS&M, M&E
Pierre Keller	Columbia University	University of California, Riverside	History
Hyunseop Kim	New York University	Seoul National University	Value
Jeffrey King	University of California, San Diego	Rutgers University	M&E
Alex Klein	Indiana University, Bloomington	California State University, Long Beach	History
Peter Klein	Yale University	Rutgers University	M&E
Matthew Kramer	Cambridge University	Cambridge University	Value
Philip Kremer	University of Pittsburgh	University of Toronto	PS&M, M&E
Uriah Kriegel	Brown University	Jean Nicod	M&E, PS&M
Frederick Kroon	Princeton University	University of Auckland	PS&M, M&E
Jennifer Lackey	Brown University	Northwestern University	M&E
Peter Lamarque	Oxford University	University of York	Value, M&E
Gerald Lang	Oxford University	University of Leeds	Value
Ben Laurence	University of Pittsburgh	University of Chicago	Value
Mi-Kyoung Lee	Harvard University	University of Colorado, Boulder	History
Brian Leftow	Yale University	Oxford University	History, M&E
Brian Leiter	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	University of Chicago	History, Value
Mary Leng	University of Toronto	York University , Toronto	PS&M
Ernest LePore	University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul	Rutgers University	M&E, PS&M
Yong Li	Saint Louis University	Wuhan	Chinese, Value
Martin Lin	University of Chicago	Rutgers University	History
Bernard Linsky	Stanford University	University of Alberta	M&E, History
Elisabeth Lloyd	Princeton University	Indiana University, Bloomington	PS&M, Feminism
Antonia LoLordo	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	University of Virginia	History
Dominic Lopes	Oxford University	University of British Columbia	Value
Edouard Machery	Sorbonne	University of Pittsburgh	M&E, PS&M
Colin Macleod	Cornell University	University of Victoria, British Columbia	Value
Penelope Maddy	Princeton University	University of California, Irvine	PS&M, M&E
Ronald Mallon	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	Washington University St. Louis	PS&M, Race, M&E, Value
Edwin Mares	Indiana University, Bloomington	Victoria University, Wellington	M&E, PS&M, History
Mohan Matthen	Stanford University	University of Toronto	History, PS&M, M&E
Robert May	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	University of California, Davis	M&E, PS&M, History
Kevin Mccain	University of Rochester	University of Alabama	M&E, PS&M
Edwin McCann	University of Pennsylvania	University of Southern California	History
Matt McGrath	Brown University	University of Missouri	M&E
Michael McKenna	University of Virginia	University of Arizona	M&E, Value
Brian McLaughlin	University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill	Rutgers University	M&E, PS&M
Jeff McMahan	Oxford University	Oxford University	Value
Lionel McPherson	Harvard University	Tufts University	Race, Value
Yitzhak Melamed	Yale University	Johns Hopkins University	History
Alfred Mele	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	Florida State University	M&E, History
Angela Mendelovici	Princeton University	University of Western Ontario	M&E, PS&M
Stephen Menn	University of Chicago	McGill	History
Alex Miller	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	Otago	M&E, Value
Cheryl Misak	Oxford University	University of Toronto	History
Friederike Moltmann	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	CNRS	M&E, PS&M
Michelle Montague	University of Colorado, Boulder	University of Texas	M&E
Christopher Morris	University of Toronto	University of Maryland	Value
John Morrison	New York University	Columbia University	M&E
Jessica Moss	Princeton University	New York University	History
Dean Moyar	University of Chicago	Johns Hopkins University	History
Dominic Murphy	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	Sydney	PS&M, M&E
Colleen Murphy	University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill	University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign	Value
Steven Nadler	Columbia University	University of Wisconsin	History
Jennifer Nagel	University of Pittsburgh	University of Toronto	M&E, PS&M, History
Bence Nanay	University of California, Berkeley	Antwerp	M&E, PS&M, Value
Alan Nelson	University of Illinois, Chicago	University North Carolina	History, P&M
Ram Neta	University of Pittsburgh	University North Carolina	M&E
Daniel Nolan	Australian National University	Australian National University	M&E, Value, PS&M
Alastair Norcross	Syracuse University	University of Colorado, Boulder	Value
Calvin Normore	University of Toronto	University of California, Los Angeles	History, PS&M, Value
Jill North	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	Cornell University	PS&M, M&E
John Norton	New South Wales	University of Pittsburgh	PS&M, M&E
Andreja Novakovic	Columbia University	University of California, Riverside	History
Martha Nussbaum	Harvard University	University of Chicago	History, Value, Feminism
Brian O'Connor	Oxford University	Dublin	History, Value
Timothy O'Connor	Cornell University	Baylor University	M&E
Samir Okasha	Oxford University	University of Bristol	PS&M, M&E
Graham Oppy	Princeton University	Monash University	M&E, Value
Peter Pagin	Stockholm	Stockholm	M&E, PS&M, History
Clare Palmer	Oxford University	Texas A&M University	Value
Robert Pasnau	Cornell University	University of Colorado, Boulder	History, M&E
Derk Pereboom	University of California, Los Angeles	Cornell University	M&E
Richard Pettigrew	University of Bristol	University of Bristol	PS&M
Gualtiero Piccinini	University of Pittsburgh	Univeristy of Missouri, St. Louis	M&E, PS&M
David Pitt	City University of New York Graduate Center	California State University, Los Angeles	M&E
Oliver Pooley	Oxford University	Oxford University	PS&M, M&E
Alexander Prescott-Couch	Harvard University	Oxford University	PS&M
Huw Price	Cambridge University	Cambridge University	PS&M, M&E
Duncan Pritchard	University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program	University of California, Irvine	M&E
Ian Proops	Harvard University	University of Texas	History, M&E
Wlodek Rabinowicz	Uppsala	Lunds	PS&M, M&E
C. Reeve	Cornell University	University North Carolina	History, Value
Michael Rescorla	Harvard University	University of California, Los Angeles	PS&M, M&E
Mathias Risse	Princeton University	Harvard University	Value, History
Michael Della Rocca	University of California, Berkeley	Yale University	History, M&E
Veronica Rodriguez-Blanco	Cambridge University	Surrey	Value
Michael Rosen	Oxford University	Harvard University	History, Value
A. Rosenberg	Johns Hopkins University	Duke University	PS&M
Paul Roth	University of Chicago	University of California, Santa Cruz	PS&M, M&E, History
Ian Rumfitt	Oxford University	Oxford University	M&E, History, Value
Joseph Salerno	Ohio State University	Saint Louis University	PS&M, M&E
Nathan Salmon	University of California, Los Angeles	University of California, Santa Barbara	M&E
Richard Samuels	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	Ohio State University	M&E, PS&M
Howard Sankey	University of Melbourne	Melbourne	PS&M
Carolina Sartorio	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	University of Arizona	M&E, Value
Stephen Schiffer	Oxford University	New York University	M&E
Tad Schmaltz	University of Notre Dame	University of Michigan	History
David Schmidtz	University of Arizona	University of Arizona	Value, PS&M, Value
Stefan Sciaraffa	University of Arizona	McMaster	Value
Russ Shafer-Landau	University of Arizona	University of Wisconsin	Value
Scott Shapiro	Columbia University	Yale University	Value, M&E
Christopher Shields	Cornell University	University of Notre Dame	History, M&E
Ted Sider	University of Massachusetts, Amherst	Cornell University	M&E
Wilfried Sieg	Stanford University	Carnegie Mellon University	PS&M, M&E
Susanna Siegel	Cornell University	Harvard University	M&E
Allan Silverman	University of California, Berkeley	Ohio State University	History
Brian Skyrms	University of Pittsburgh	University of California, Irvine	PS&M, M&E
Chris Smeenk	University of Pittsburgh	University of Western Ontario	PS&M, History
Sonja Smets	Free Univeristy of Brussels	Amsterdam	PS&M, M&E
Nicholas Smith	Stanford University	Lewis & Clark	History
David Sosa	Princeton University	University of Texas	M&E, Value
Ernest Sosa	University of Pittsburgh	Rutgers University	M&E
Robert Stainton	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	University of Western Ontario	M&E, PS&M
Aaron Stalnaker	Brown University	Indiana University, Bloomington	Chinese, M&E
Kyle Stanford	University of California, San Diego	University of California, Irvine	PS&M
Kim Sterelny	University of Sydney	Australian National University	PS&M, M&E
Matthias Steup	Brown University	University of Colorado, Boulder	M&E
Stephen Stich	Princeton University	Rutgers University	M&E, PS&M, Value
Michael Strevens	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	New York University	PS&M
Eleonore Stump	Cornell University	Saint Louis University	History, M&E
Robert Talisse	City University of New York Graduate Center	Vanderbilt University	History, Value
John Tasioulas	Oxford University	King's College, London	Value
Larry Temkin	Princeton University	Rutgers University	Value
Iain Thomson	University of California, San Diego	University of New Mexico	History
Justin Tiwald	University of Chicago	San Francisco State University	Value, Chinese
Charles Travis	University of California, Los Angeles	King's College London	M&E, History
J.D. Trout	Cornell University	Loyola/Chicago	PS&M, M&E
John Turri	Brown University	University of Waterloo	M&E, PS&M
Gabriel Uzquiano	Massachusetts Institute of Technology	University of Southern California	PS&M, M&E
Peter Vallentyne	University of Pittsburgh	University of Missouri	Value, PS&M
Bryan van Norden	Stanford University	Vassar	Chinese, Value
Somogy Varga	Goethe Universität, Frankfurt am Main	University of Memphis	PS&M, M&E, Value
Manuel Vargas	Stanford University	University of California, San Diego	M&E, Value, Race
Katja Vogt	Munich	Columbia University	History, Value
David Wallace	Oxford University	University of Southern California	PS&M
Wil Waluchow	Oxford University	McMaster	Value
Ted Warfield	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	University of Notre Dame	M&E, Value
Georgia Warnke	Boston University	University of California, Riverside	History, Value, Feminism
Eric Watkins	University of Notre Dame	University of California, San Diego	History
Jonathan Weinberg	Rutgers University, New Brunswick	University of Arizona	M&E, PS&M, Value
Michael Weisberg	Stanford University	University of Pennsylvania	PS&M
Eric Wiland	University of Chicago	Univeristy of Missouri, St. Louis	Value
Thomas Williams	University of Notre Dame	University of South Florida	History, M&E
Timothy Williamson	Oxford University	Oxford University	M&E, PS&M, Value
Robert Wilson	Cornell University	Latrobe	M&E, PS&M
Eric Winsberg	Indiana University, Bloomington	University of South Florida	PS&M
Allen Wood	Yale University	Indiana University, Bloomington	History, Value
Mark Wrathall	University of California, Berkeley	Oxford University	History
Christian Wuthrich	University of Pittsburgh	Geneva	PS&M, M&E
Gideon Yaffe	Stanford University	Yale University	M&E, History, Value
Jose Zalabardo	University of Michigan, Ann Arbor	University College London	History, M&E
Dean Zimmerman	Brown University	Rutgers University	M&E

Name

PhD School

Current School

AREAS

Anna Alexandrova

University of California, San Diego

Cambridge University

PS&M, M&E

Torin Alter

University of California, Los Angeles

University of Alabama

M&E

Mark Alznauer

University of Chicago

Northwestern University

History

Kristin Andrews

University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul

York University , Toronto

PS&M

Stephen Angle

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

Wesleyn

Value, Chinese

Kwame Anthony Appiah

Cambridge University

New York University

Race, Feminism, Value

Avery Archer

University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program

George Washington University

M&E, Value, PS&M

Andre Ariew

University of Arizona

University of Missouri

PS&M

Brad Armendt

University of Illinois, Chicago

Arizona State University

PS&M, M&E

Joachim Aufderheide

University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program

King's College, London

History

Murat Aydede

University of Maryland

University of British Columbia

M&E, PS&M

David Bakhurst

Oxford University

Queen's University

M&E, Value

Rachel Barney

Princeton University

University of Toronto

History, Value

Jeffrey Barrett

Columbia University

University of California, Irvine

PS&M, M&E

John Bengson

University of Texas, Austin

University of Wisconsin

M&E, Value

Jose Bermudez

Cambridge University

Texas A&M University

M&E, PS&M

Sven Bernecker

Stanford University

University of California, Irvine

M&E, PS&M

Jessica Berry

University of Texas, Austin

Georgia State University

History

Christopher Bertram

University College London

University of Bristol

Value

Cristina Bicchieri

Cambridge University

University of Pennsylvania

PS&M, Value, M&E

John Bickle

University of California, Irvine

Missisippi State University

PS&M, M&E

Alexander Bird

Cambridge University

University of Bristol

PS&M, M&E

Brian Bix

Oxford University

University of Minnesota

Value

Chris Bobonich

University of California, Berkeley

Stanford University

History, Value

Paul Boghossian

Princeton University

New York University

M&E

David Bourget

Australian National University

University of Western Ontario

M&E, PS&M

David Braddon-Mitchell

Australian National University

Sydney

M&E, PS&M

David Braun

University of California, Los Angeles

University at Buffalo

M&E

Lee Braver

Emory University

University of South Florida

History

Tad Brennan

Princeton University

Cornell University

History

Bill Brewer

Oxford University

King's College, London

M&E

Berit Brogaard

University at Buffalo

University of Miami

M&E, PS&M

John Brunero

Columbia University

University of Nebraska

Value

Lara Buchak

Princeton University

University of California, Berkeley

PS&M, M&E

Alex Byrne

Princeton University

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

M&E, PS&M

Agnes Callard

University of California, Berkeley

University of Chicago

History, M&E, Value

Taylor Carman

Stanford University

Columbia University

History

John Carriero

Harvard University

University of California, Los Angeles

History, M&E

Peter Carruthers

Oxford University

University of Maryland

M&E, PS&M, History

Thomas Carson

Brown University

Loyola/Chicago

Value, History

Victor Caston

University of Texas, Austin)

University of Michigan

History

Mazviita Chirimuuta

University of Bristol

University of Pittsburgh

PS&M, M&E

Maudemarie Clark

University of Wisconsin, Madison

University of California, Riverside

History

Jonathan Cohen

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of California, San Diego

M&E, Value, PS&M

Juan Comesaña

Brown University

University of Arizona

M&E

Kevin Connolly

University of Toronto

Minerva Schools at KGI

PS&M, M&E

Roger Crisp

Oxford University

Value

Steven Crowell

Yale University

Rice University

History

Javier Cumpa

Madrid)

Madrid

PS&M, M&E

Gregory Currie

University of California, Berkeley

University of York

Value, M&E

David Danks

University of California, San Diego

Carnegie Mellon University

PS&M

Stephen Darwall

University of Pittsburgh

Yale University

Value, History

Shamik Dasgupta

New York University

University of California, Berkeley

M&E, PS&M

Stephen Davies

University College London

University of Auckland

Value

Jake Davis

City University of New York Graduate Center

New York University

Chinese, Value, PS&M

Keith DeRose

University of California, Los Angeles

Yale University

M&E

Dan Devereux

University of Chicago

University of Virginia

History, Value

John Doris

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

Washington University St. Louis

Value, PS&M, M&E

Stephen Downes

Virginia Tech

University of Utah

PS&M, M&E

James Dreier

Princeton University

Brown University

Value

Julia Driver

Johns Hopkins University

Washington University St. Louis

Value

Gerald Dworkin

University of California, Berkeley

University of California, Davis

Value

David Ebrey

University of California, Los Angeles

University of California, Berkeley

History

William Edmundson

University of California, Berkeley

Georgia State University

Value

Frances Egan

University of Western Ontario

Rutgers University

M&E, PS&M

Marc Ereshefsky

University of Wisconsin, Madison

University of Calgary

PS&M

Jeremy Fantl

Brown University

University of Calgary

M&E

Matthew Festenstein

Cambridge University

York University , Toronto

History, Value

Johann Frick

Harvard University

Princeton University

Value

Daniel Garber

Harvard University

Princeton University

History, P&M

Sebastian Gardner

Cambridge University

University College London

History, Value

Aaron Garrett

New School SR

Boston University

History

Don Garrett

Yale University

New York University

History

Gerald Gaus

University of Pittsburgh

University of Arizona

Value, PS&M

Berys Gaut

Princeton University

St. Andrews/Stirling

Value

Ken Gemes

University of Pittsburgh

Birkbeck

History, P&M

Rocco Gennaro

Syracuse University

Southern Indiana

M&E, Value, History, PS&M

Margaret Gilbert

Oxford University

University of California, Irvine

M&E, PS&M, Value

Michael Gill

University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

University of Arizona

History

Anthony Gillies

University of Arizona

Rutgers University

PS&M, M&E

Michael Giudice

McMaster University

York University , Toronto

Value

Warren Goldfarb

Harvard University

M&E, PS&M, History

Alvin Goldman

Princeton University

Rutgers University

M&E, Value, PS&M

John Greco

Brown University

Saint Louis University

M&E

Leslie J. Green

Oxford University

Value, Feminism

Paul Griffiths

Australian National University

Sydney

PS&M

Stephen Grimm

University of Notre Dame

Fordham

M&E, Value

Gary Gutting

Saint Louis University

University of Notre Dame

History, PS&M, M&E

Paul Guyer

Harvard University

Brown University

History, Value

Ben Hale

Stony Brook

University of Colorado, Boulder

Value

Michael Hardimon

University of Chicago

University of California, San Diego

Race, History

William Harper

University of Rochester

University of Western Ontario

History

Verity Harte

Cambridge University

Yale University

History, M&E

John Hawthorne

Syracuse University

University of Southern California

M&E, History

Benjamin Hellie

Princeton University

University of Toronto

M&E, PS&M

David Hilbert

Stanford University

University of Illinois, Chicago

M&E, PS&M

Barry hilbert

Stanford University

Rutgers University

M&E, PS&M

Christopher Hill

Harvard University

Brown University

M&E

Chris Hitchcock

University of Pittsburgh

CalTech

PS&M, M&E

Wesley Holliday

Stanford University

University of California, Berkeley

M&E, PS&M

Robert Hopkins

Cambridge University

New York University

Value, M&E, History

Leon Horsten

Leuven

University of Bristol

PS&M, M&E

John Horty

University of Pittsburgh

University of Maryland

M&E, PS&M, Value

Stephen Houlgate

University of Edinburgh

University of Warwick

History

Andrew Huddleston

Princeton University

Birkbeck

History, Value

Michael Huemer

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of Colorado, Boulder

M&E, Value

Nicholas Huggett

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of Illinois, Chicago

PS&M

Simon Hutteger

Salzburg

University of California, Irvine

PS&M, M&E

Thomas Icard

Stanford University

M&E, PS&M

Brad Inwood

University of Toronto

Yale University

History

Terence Irwin

Princeton University

Oxford University

History, Value

Henry Jackman

University of Pittsburgh

York University , Toronto

History, M&E

Anne Jacobson

Oxford University

Harvard University

M&E, PS&M, Feminism

Scott Jenkins

Princeton University

University of Kansas

History

Robin Jeshion

University of Chicago

University of Southern California

M&E, History

Thomas Johansen

Cambridge University

Oslo

History, M&E, Value

Jim Joyce

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

University of Michigan

PS&M, M&E

Shelly Kagan

Princeton University

Yale University

Value

Peter Kail

Cambridge University

Oxford University

History, M&E

Paul Katsafanas

Harvard University

Boston University

Value, M&E, History

Dan Kaufman

University of Massachusetts, Amherst

University of Colorado, Boulder

History, M&E

John Kearns

Yale University

University at Buffalo

PS&M, M&E

Pierre Keller

Columbia University

University of California, Riverside

History

Hyunseop Kim

New York University

Seoul National University

Value

Jeffrey King

University of California, San Diego

Rutgers University

M&E

Alex Klein

Indiana University, Bloomington

California State University, Long Beach

History

Peter Klein

Yale University

Rutgers University

M&E

Matthew Kramer

Cambridge University

Value

Philip Kremer

University of Pittsburgh

University of Toronto

PS&M, M&E

Uriah Kriegel

Brown University

Jean Nicod

M&E, PS&M

Frederick Kroon

Princeton University

University of Auckland

PS&M, M&E

Jennifer Lackey

Brown University

Northwestern University

M&E

Peter Lamarque

Oxford University

University of York

Value, M&E

Gerald Lang

Oxford University

University of Leeds

Value

Ben Laurence

University of Pittsburgh

University of Chicago

Value

Mi-Kyoung Lee

Harvard University

University of Colorado, Boulder

History

Brian Leftow

Yale University

Oxford University

History, M&E

Brian Leiter

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

University of Chicago

History, Value

Mary Leng

University of Toronto

York University , Toronto

PS&M

Ernest LePore

University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul

Rutgers University

M&E, PS&M

Yong Li

Saint Louis University

Wuhan

Chinese, Value

Martin Lin

University of Chicago

Rutgers University

History

Bernard Linsky

Stanford University

University of Alberta

M&E, History

Elisabeth Lloyd

Princeton University

Indiana University, Bloomington

PS&M, Feminism

Antonia LoLordo

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of Virginia

History

Dominic Lopes

Oxford University

University of British Columbia

Value

Edouard Machery

Sorbonne

University of Pittsburgh

M&E, PS&M

Colin Macleod

Cornell University

University of Victoria, British Columbia

Value

Penelope Maddy

Princeton University

University of California, Irvine

PS&M, M&E

Ronald Mallon

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

Washington University St. Louis

PS&M, Race, M&E, Value

Edwin Mares

Indiana University, Bloomington

Victoria University, Wellington

M&E, PS&M, History

Mohan Matthen

Stanford University

University of Toronto

History, PS&M, M&E

Robert May

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

University of California, Davis

M&E, PS&M, History

Kevin Mccain

University of Rochester

University of Alabama

M&E, PS&M

Edwin McCann

University of Pennsylvania

University of Southern California

History

Matt McGrath

Brown University

University of Missouri

M&E

Michael McKenna

University of Virginia

University of Arizona

M&E, Value

Brian McLaughlin

University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

Rutgers University

M&E, PS&M

Jeff McMahan

Oxford University

Value

Lionel McPherson

Harvard University

Tufts University

Race, Value

Yitzhak Melamed

Yale University

Johns Hopkins University

History

Alfred Mele

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

Florida State University

M&E, History

Angela Mendelovici

Princeton University

University of Western Ontario

M&E, PS&M

Stephen Menn

University of Chicago

McGill

History

Alex Miller

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

Otago

M&E, Value

Cheryl Misak

Oxford University

University of Toronto

History

Friederike Moltmann

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

CNRS

M&E, PS&M

Michelle Montague

University of Colorado, Boulder

University of Texas

M&E

Christopher Morris

University of Toronto

University of Maryland

Value

John Morrison

New York University

Columbia University

M&E

Jessica Moss

Princeton University

New York University

History

Dean Moyar

University of Chicago

Johns Hopkins University

History

Dominic Murphy

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

Sydney

PS&M, M&E

Colleen Murphy

University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill

University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

Value

Steven Nadler

Columbia University

University of Wisconsin

History

Jennifer Nagel

University of Pittsburgh

University of Toronto

M&E, PS&M, History

Bence Nanay

University of California, Berkeley

Antwerp

M&E, PS&M, Value

Alan Nelson

University of Illinois, Chicago

University North Carolina

History, P&M

Ram Neta

University of Pittsburgh

University North Carolina

M&E

Daniel Nolan

Australian National University

M&E, Value, PS&M

Alastair Norcross

Syracuse University

University of Colorado, Boulder

Value

Calvin Normore

University of Toronto

University of California, Los Angeles

History, PS&M, Value

Jill North

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

Cornell University

PS&M, M&E

John Norton

New South Wales

University of Pittsburgh

PS&M, M&E

Andreja Novakovic

Columbia University

University of California, Riverside

History

Martha Nussbaum

Harvard University

University of Chicago

History, Value, Feminism

Brian O'Connor

Oxford University

Dublin

History, Value

Timothy O'Connor

Cornell University

Baylor University

M&E

Samir Okasha

Oxford University

University of Bristol

PS&M, M&E

Graham Oppy

Princeton University

Monash University

M&E, Value

Peter Pagin

Stockholm

M&E, PS&M, History

Clare Palmer

Oxford University

Texas A&M University

Value

Robert Pasnau

Cornell University

University of Colorado, Boulder

History, M&E

Derk Pereboom

University of California, Los Angeles

Cornell University

M&E

Richard Pettigrew

University of Bristol

PS&M

Gualtiero Piccinini

University of Pittsburgh

Univeristy of Missouri, St. Louis

M&E, PS&M

David Pitt

City University of New York Graduate Center

California State University, Los Angeles

M&E

Oliver Pooley

Oxford University

PS&M, M&E

Alexander Prescott-Couch

Harvard University

Oxford University

PS&M

Huw Price

Cambridge University

PS&M, M&E

Duncan Pritchard

University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program

University of California, Irvine

M&E

Ian Proops

Harvard University

University of Texas

History, M&E

Wlodek Rabinowicz

Uppsala

Lunds

PS&M, M&E

C. Reeve

Cornell University

University North Carolina

History, Value

Michael Rescorla

Harvard University

University of California, Los Angeles

PS&M, M&E

Mathias Risse

Princeton University

Harvard University

Value, History

Michael Della Rocca

University of California, Berkeley

Yale University

History, M&E

Veronica Rodriguez-Blanco

Cambridge University

Surrey

Value

Michael Rosen

Oxford University

Harvard University

History, Value

A. Rosenberg

Johns Hopkins University

Duke University

PS&M

Paul Roth

University of Chicago

University of California, Santa Cruz

PS&M, M&E, History

Ian Rumfitt

Oxford University

M&E, History, Value

Joseph Salerno

Ohio State University

Saint Louis University

PS&M, M&E

Nathan Salmon

University of California, Los Angeles

University of California, Santa Barbara

M&E

Richard Samuels

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

Ohio State University

M&E, PS&M

Howard Sankey

University of Melbourne

Melbourne

PS&M

Carolina Sartorio

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

University of Arizona

M&E, Value

Stephen Schiffer

Oxford University

New York University

M&E

Tad Schmaltz

University of Notre Dame

University of Michigan

History

David Schmidtz

University of Arizona

Value, PS&M, Value

Stefan Sciaraffa

University of Arizona

McMaster

Value

Russ Shafer-Landau

University of Arizona

University of Wisconsin

Value

Scott Shapiro

Columbia University

Yale University

Value, M&E

Christopher Shields

Cornell University

University of Notre Dame

History, M&E

Ted Sider

University of Massachusetts, Amherst

Cornell University

M&E

Wilfried Sieg

Stanford University

Carnegie Mellon University

PS&M, M&E

Susanna Siegel

Cornell University

Harvard University

M&E

Allan Silverman

University of California, Berkeley

Ohio State University

History

Brian Skyrms

University of Pittsburgh

University of California, Irvine

PS&M, M&E

Chris Smeenk

University of Pittsburgh

University of Western Ontario

PS&M, History

Sonja Smets

Free Univeristy of Brussels

Amsterdam

PS&M, M&E

Nicholas Smith

Stanford University

Lewis & Clark

History

David Sosa

Princeton University

University of Texas

M&E, Value

Ernest Sosa

University of Pittsburgh

Rutgers University

M&E

Robert Stainton

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

University of Western Ontario

M&E, PS&M

Aaron Stalnaker

Brown University

Indiana University, Bloomington

Chinese, M&E

Kyle Stanford

University of California, San Diego

University of California, Irvine

PS&M

Kim Sterelny

University of Sydney

Australian National University

PS&M, M&E

Matthias Steup

Brown University

University of Colorado, Boulder

M&E

Stephen Stich

Princeton University

Rutgers University

M&E, PS&M, Value

Michael Strevens

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

New York University

PS&M

Eleonore Stump

Cornell University

Saint Louis University

History, M&E

Robert Talisse

City University of New York Graduate Center

Vanderbilt University

History, Value

John Tasioulas

Oxford University

King's College, London

Value

Larry Temkin

Princeton University

Rutgers University

Value

Iain Thomson

University of California, San Diego

University of New Mexico

History

Justin Tiwald

University of Chicago

San Francisco State University

Value, Chinese

Charles Travis

University of California, Los Angeles

King's College London

M&E, History

J.D. Trout

Cornell University

Loyola/Chicago

PS&M, M&E

John Turri

Brown University

University of Waterloo

M&E, PS&M

Gabriel Uzquiano

Massachusetts Institute of Technology

University of Southern California

PS&M, M&E

Peter Vallentyne

University of Pittsburgh

University of Missouri

Value, PS&M

Bryan van Norden

Stanford University

Vassar

Chinese, Value

Somogy Varga

Goethe Universität, Frankfurt am Main

University of Memphis

PS&M, M&E, Value

Manuel Vargas

Stanford University

University of California, San Diego

M&E, Value, Race

Katja Vogt

Munich

Columbia University

History, Value

David Wallace

Oxford University

University of Southern California

PS&M

Wil Waluchow

Oxford University

McMaster

Value

Ted Warfield

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of Notre Dame

M&E, Value

Georgia Warnke

Boston University

University of California, Riverside

History, Value, Feminism

Eric Watkins

University of Notre Dame

University of California, San Diego

History

Jonathan Weinberg

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

University of Arizona

M&E, PS&M, Value

Michael Weisberg

Stanford University

University of Pennsylvania

PS&M

Eric Wiland

University of Chicago

Univeristy of Missouri, St. Louis

Value

Thomas Williams

University of Notre Dame

University of South Florida

History, M&E

Timothy Williamson

Oxford University

M&E, PS&M, Value

Robert Wilson

Cornell University

Latrobe

M&E, PS&M

Eric Winsberg

Indiana University, Bloomington

University of South Florida

PS&M

Allen Wood

Yale University

Indiana University, Bloomington

History, Value

Mark Wrathall

University of California, Berkeley

Oxford University

History

Christian Wuthrich

University of Pittsburgh

Geneva

PS&M, M&E

Gideon Yaffe

Stanford University

Yale University

M&E, History, Value

Jose Zalabardo

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

University College London

History, M&E

Dean Zimmerman

Brown University

Rutgers University

M&E