Evaluators were asked not to evaluate either their own department or the department from which they received their highest degree (PhD, DPhil, sometimes the BPhil) and were told that such ratings would be removed. All instances of improper or stray ratings were removed from the survey data.
| ADVISOR | UNIVERSITY | ADVISOR | UNIVERSITY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rachel Barney | University of Toronto | Ian Phillips | Johns Hopkins University |
| Jeffrey Barrett | University of California, Irvine | Hanna Pickard | Johns Hopkins University |
| Gwen Bradford | University of Toronto | Michael Rosen | Harvard University |
| Keith DeRose | Yale University | Alex Rosenberg | Duke University |
| John Doris | Cornell University | David Schmidtz | University of Arizona |
| Don Garrett | New York University | Christopher Shields | University of California, San Diego |
| Stephan Hartmann | LMU, Munich | Brian Skyrms | University of California, Irvine |
| Christopher Hitchcock | California Instititute of Technology | Stephen Stich | Rutgers University, New Brunswick |
| Jenann Ismael | Johns Hopkins University | Iain Thomson | University of New Mexico |
| Shelly Kagan | Yale University | Justin Tiwald | University of Hong Kong |
| Niko Kolodny | University of California, Berkeley | Katja Vogt | Columbia University |
| Brian Leiter (Founding Editor) | University of Chicago | Ted Warfield | University of Notre Dame |
| Edouard Machery | University of Pittsburgh | Tim Williamson | Oxford University |
| Angela Mendelovici | University of Western Ontario | Jessica Wilson | University of Toronto |
| Mark Murphy | Georgetown University |